Breaking News: Gubernatorial Candidates: Stand-Up Comedy- Part of their Campaign Strategy

Most Read

In what experienced political strategists are calling either “a bold campaign pivot” or “clear evidence the election season has gone completely off the rails,” Republican gubernatorial candidate Jack Ciattarelli and Democratic contender Mikie Sherrill took to the stage at Catch a Rising Star in Princeton last open mic night to test their comedy chops before a bewildered audience of 47 people who thought they were going to see new talent trying out comedy material, but instead were forced to watch the two New Jersey gubernatorial hopefuls.

The evening opened with Ciattarelli approaching the microphone wearing what appeared to be the same suit he’s worn to every campaign event since 2019. “So I was talking to my wife about property taxes,” he began, pausing for laughter that was brief. “She said, ‘Jack, our property taxes are so high, even the house is considering moving to Pennsylvania.’ I said, ‘Honey, if we move to Pennsylvania, we’ll have to start rooting for Philadelphia sports teams.’ Now THAT’S cruel and unusual punishment!”

The crowd’s polite golf claps were interrupted when someone heckled in the back, “Is this part of his platform?”

Sherrill, taking the stage in her signature navy blazer, immediately launched into material clearly workshopped by her campaign committee and political consultants. “You know you’re from New Jersey when your GPS has three settings: fastest route, shortest route, and ‘avoid construction on Route 287 for the next decade.’” When the audience chuckled just a bit, she doubled down: “Speaking of construction, my opponent wants to build his political career on the foundation of failed policies. I prefer infrastructure you can actually drive on without damaging your suspension.”

Local comedy veteran Tony DeMarcus, whose credits include opening for Tubby Boots and ‘An Evening of Laughter’ on local Bayonne cable, watched from the wings with joyful glee. “After watching this,” he shared, “This audience will certainly be primed for my ‘socks in a dryer’ and ‘the difference between cats and dogs’ very original routines.” 

The evening’s high point came when both candidates attempted crowd work. Ciattarelli spotted a man in a Mets cap and said, “Mets fan, huh? I bet you’re kinda disappointed this season! Kind of like New Jersey voters with Democrats in office!” The man responded, “I’m from Connecticut and I’m just here visiting my daughter.” Sherrill immediately chimed in: “Well, at least Connecticut has lower property taxes and functional mass transit!”

By intermission, much of the audience members had left, a few others were openly scrolling their phones, and one elderly woman was heard asking her husband, “Has our chicken tenders and fries arrived yet?”

The candidates’ respective campaign managers offered wildly different takes on the evening’s success. Ciattarelli’s team issued a statement calling the performance “a home run of comedy quips that really connected with working families,” while Sherrill’s camp described it as “a thoughtful exploration of policy through the lens of humor that demonstrated her ability to connect across the aisle.”

Neither statement addressed why Ciattarelli spent seven minutes explaining his plan to reduce regulatory burden through what he called “bureaucratic limbo” or why Sherrill’s closing bit involved a detailed breakdown of her experience as a helicopter pilot delivered in the style of a knock-knock joke.

Club manager Eddie Trachtenberg seemed philosophical about the evening. “Look, I’ve had worse shows. There was that time in ‘97 when ventriloquist John Lombardi’s dummy caught fire. But usually when politicians try this hard, they at least do it at a town hall instead of my comedy club.”

When asked if either candidate showed promise for a second career in entertainment, former SNL staff writer Sarah Jane Bene was diplomatic: “Let’s just say they should definitely keep their day jobs. Well, technically they’re both trying to get the same day job, which explains a lot about this whole situation.”

Both campaigns have announced they will continue their “listening tour” of unique New Jersey venues, with upcoming stops planned at a karaoke bar in Hoboken and a paint-and-sip studio in Cherry Hill. Tickets for those events are reportedly still available.

The comedy show concluded with both candidates on stage together for what was billed as a “bipartisan closing number” but devolved into them taking turns reading their campaign websites aloud while occasionally saying “ba-dum-tss.”

- Advertisement -spot_img

More articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -spot_img

Latest article